Civil Rights Groups Oppose Proposed Changes That Would Illegally Dismantle the Head Start Program
Proposed rule would weaken longstanding protections that ensure children receive high-quality, comprehensive services
WASHINGTON — Today, civil right groups filed a public comment in opposition to a rule proposed by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services’ Administration for Children and Families, urging the agency to withdraw its proposed changes to the Head Start Program Performance Standards. The proposal would remove many of the standards that have made Head Start one of the nation’s most successful investments in young children and families and would make it harder for local programs to provide the high-quality services children deserve.
Head Start’s performance standards establish minimum protections to ensure children receive high-quality education, developmental screenings, qualified teachers, and comprehensive support regardless of where they live. Removing those protections would create uncertainty for families and weaken accountability for taxpayers.
“These proposed changes are unlawful. Congress requires HHS to protect the quality, scope, and type of services Head Start provides, and to ensure Head Start programs provide linguistically and culturally relevant comprehensive services. The administration cannot simply disregard those directives. This proposal would weaken standards that families have relied on for generations and undermine a program Congress specifically acted to protect,” said Jennesa Calvo-Friedman, senior staff attorney at the ACLU Women’s Rights Project. “By making Head Start programs less accessible, this proposed rule threatens women’s economic and social freedom and risks pushing them out of the workforce and back into the home.”
“Head Start serves thousands of children and families across Illinois, providing a critical boost for success and creating opportunity in our state,” said Allison N. Siebeneck, director of the Women’s and Reproductive Rights Project at the ACLU of Illinois. “The Administration has been determined to undermine – indeed dismantle – Head Start since taking office last year. They failed legislatively to achieve this goal and are attempting to accomplish the same end via these rule changes. We are proud to stand with our colleagues and partners in opposing this destructive and harmful effort.”
“Head Start is a critically important support for children, families, and entire communities facing barriers that arise from systemic racism and inequality – a purpose Congress specifically created it for. As the Administration continues its attempt to unravel Head Start, this time through rulemaking, we continue our fight to stop any attempt to restrict meaningful access to this vital program,” said La Rond Baker, ACLU of Washington legal director.
“Head Start exists to make sure every child in the United States has access to comprehensive education. The proposed Rule undercuts that purpose,” said Lori Rifkin, Impact Fund litigation director. “It erases crucial access requirements for the children most likely to be left behind, including children with disabilities, children in rural communities, children in foster care, and Black and brown children. The Administration's attacks on Head Start have been rejected by Congress and the federal courts, and we will continue to stand with Head Start programs and families to fight these illegal acts.”
For more than 60 years, Head Start has combined early learning with health care, developmental screenings, nutrition, family support, disability services, and parent engagement. Decades of research show that this comprehensive approach improves school readiness, as well as health, educational attainment, and long-term outcomes for children and families.
Rather than providing meaningful flexibility, the proposal removes safeguards that protect children while providing no additional funding to address rising costs for staffing, food, transportation, insurance, and facilities. Programs would be left with fewer resources and fewer protections to maintain high-quality services.
The comment was submitted by the American Civil Liberties Union’s Women’s Rights Project, the ACLU of Washington, ACLU of Illinois, and Impact Fund. The group also represents a coalition of Head Start parents and providers that successfully halted previous attempts from the Trump administration to gut the Head Start program. Those attempts included a sprawling “DEIA” ban, restrictions of eligibility for many immigrant families, and cuts to more than half of the staff at the Office of Head Start, that likewise sought to fundamentally alter what Head Start providers could teach and the communities they could serve.
The full public comment is available here.